Holiday Mystery Pack: The Under-the-Tree 12pk 12x750ml

Some bottles are too legendary to leave above ground.

Behind an iron gate and a heavy stone door, far from the light, lies the Crypt, where we seal away the wines we'd rather keep for ourselves. Every one of its twelve reds is rated 94 points or higher. This is a collector's cellar laid to rest in a single box, waiting for someone brave enough to wake it up.

The first spirits you'll meet read like a map of Napa Valley's most storied grounds. There's a 95-point Cabernet from Oakville, sacred ground for some of the most celebrated vineyards in America. Next is a 96-point Rutherford Cabernet that Vinous ranked #4 on its Top 100 Wines of 2025. Rutherford is famous for its dusty, savory edge, and this bottle carries that ghostly signature beautifully. A 95-point Coombsville Cabernet adds a cool, elegant whisper of Napa, the kind of wine that makes sommeliers lean in closer.

Beyond the valley walls, you'll find the #1 selling Paso Robles Cabernet, a bold, dark California Cab with enough depth to keep you up past midnight. Then comes the phantom of the Crypt: a 98-point Super Tuscan that Jeb Dunnuck ranked #42 on his Top 100 Wines of 2025. It's rich, precise, and unforgettable, the kind of bottle that will haunt your memory long after the last drop.

Those five bottles alone carry $490 in retail value. The seven bottles resting beside them are just as formidable, all 94 points or higher. They include Amarone with its dark, dried-fruit richness, Brunello with its classic Tuscan grip, more top-tier Napa Cabernet, and other bottles collectors hunt for in the shadows. Every wine in this case could command its own candlelit dinner.

It's the kind of cellar most people spend years building, bottle by bottle, and this one rises from the tomb in a single box. Save a few for the holidays, lay a couple down for the long haul, and don't be afraid to open one on a random Wednesday. The best wines deserve to be enjoyed, not just admired from behind the gate.

The full case carries a retail value of $1,215, and it's yours for $599 with shipping included. That's 51% off, or about $50 a bottle, for wines that regularly sell for $85 to $125. The Crypt is open. Enter, if you dare.