Want to find a great 90+ rated red wine for under $25? With thousands of options, how does one choose? Here’s a shortcut to 10 delicious bottles that deliver great quality and value.
If you want the experts to guide you, jump to the end and take advantage of the case offer.
2020 Tenuta del Pajaru Paritaru Negroamaro
Negroamaro fans, take note—the 2020 Tenuta del Pajaru Paritaru Negroamaro is a bold, expressive red straight from the heart of Puglia. This wine captures the sun-drenched essence of Southern Italy with its deep, dark fruit, soft spice, and earthy undertones. If you love full-bodied, dry reds with character and a rustic edge, this one delivers in spades. It’s a soulful bottle that speaks of tradition, warmth, and the rich winemaking heritage of the Salento region. A true Southern Italian gem, perfect for pairing with hearty meals or enjoying on its own.. 
2020 Steele Cabernet Franc Lake County
At Shannon Family of Wines, the commitment to the environment isn't just a phase, it's a lifestyle that’s impregnated into every aspect of the family’s operations. The accolades, including the California Green Medal Environment Award, stand as proof of their unwavering dedication. The winery is Sustainable Certified, and they’re on their way to becoming one of the largest Certified Organic mountain-grown vineyards in the U.S
2021 Invivo Pinot Noir Central Otago New Zealand
This isn’t just any Pinot Noir; it’s the life of your next dinner party. Expect notes of ripe cherry, wild strawberries, and a subtle hint of earthy magic—like a walk in the woods with a bowl of berries. It’s as at home paired with roast lamb as it is with your guilty-pleasure Netflix binge and a bowl of truffle popcorn.
2020 Poderi Angelini Susumaniello Tarantino Puglia
A rich and vibrant red wine that captures the essence of Southern Italy. It offers bold flavors of ripe blackberries, cherries, and plums, with subtle notes of Mediterranean herbs and spice. Smooth tannins and bright acidity create a well-balanced wine that pairs beautifully with grilled meats or hearty pasta dishes. Robust, expressive, and deeply satisfying—this Susumaniello delivers a delicious taste of Puglia with every glass.
2021 Sella & Mosca Carignano Terre Rare Riserva Sardinia
Sella & Mosca embodies the rich heritage and bold spirit of Sardinia, where centuries-old traditions blend seamlessly with modern winemaking expertise. The 2021 Carignano Terre Rare Riserva is a powerful expression of this unique terroir. On the palate, it reveals structured tannins and vibrant acidity, showcasing deep layers of dark berries, Mediterranean herbs, and subtle mineral notes. This wine captures the essence of Sardinia’s rugged landscape while offering elegance and complexity that reflect its prestigious Riserva status.
2020 San Ferdinando Ciliegiolo Toscana IGT
The 2020 San Ferdinando Ciliegiolo is turning heads in Tuscany—and now it’s your turn to taste why. This expressive red is bursting with juicy red cherry, plum, and floral notes, accented by a touch of spice and earth. Silky tannins and bright acidity give it a smooth, balanced feel from start to finish. A true hidden gem from the Tuscan hills, this wine offers character, charm, and outstanding value for any Italian wine lover.
2018 Cantariña Viña de Los Pinos Mencia Bierzo Spain
2018 Cantariña Viña de Los Pinos Mencia is one of the hidden gems in Bierzo. An icon. The result is impressive. A fresh and easy-to-drink Spanish red blend. Decanter called it."A benchmark for natural wine lovers." This wine has a very limited production.
2021 Pasetti Madonnella Montepulciano D’Abruzzo DOP
Montepulciano d’Abruzzo is one of Italy’s most beloved reds, known for its bold character and easy charm. Grown in the rolling hills of Abruzzo along the Adriatic coast, this 2021 Madonnella delivers all the rich flavor the region is known for. It’s smooth, balanced, and full of dark fruit, with just a touch of spice. A true taste of southern Italy, this wine is both versatile and crowd-pleasing—the perfect bottle for any night of the week.
2018 Mannucci Droandi Chianti Classico Ceppetto Alto DOCG
This wine is of high quality and a great expression of the terroir. With multiple 90+ reviews from major wine critics, including James Suckling who said this is a "fruity and savory" Chianti and WinesCritic describing its "excellent quality and brightness," the 2018 Mannucci Droandi Chianti Ceppetto Alto DOCG certainly lives up to the family name.
2022 Talosa Rosso Di Montepulciano DOC
Talosa Rosso Di Montepulciano DOC is a beautiful and fresh wine, and it's ready to drink today! This wine will be your new go-to daily drinker. It pairs with best friends and good times! Vino Nobile di Montepulciano is the first Italian DOC. This place, -also referred to as “The King of All Wines”- was known to be the favorite of some of the most influential Popes, Kings, and Presidents of Italy. Montepulciano in Tuscany holds some of the world’s greatest hidden treasures. One of them is Fattoria Della Talosa.
2022 Château De Carles Fronsac Bordeaux
The 2022 Château De Carles Fronsac Bordeaux is a polished, Merlot-dominant red from the Right Bank of Bordeaux that delivers classic elegance and structure with a modern edge. Grown on limestone-rich soils overlooking the Dordogne River, this wine opens with aromas of blackcurrant, plum, and graphite, followed by hints of cedar, violets, and toasted oak. On the palate, it’s refined and supple, with silky tannins and a long, harmonious finish. A top-value Bordeaux that punches well above its price point—perfect for fans of polished, fruit-forward reds with old-world finesse.
2021 Penley Estate Tolmer Cabernet Sauvignon Coonawarra Australia
The 2021 Penley Estate Tolmer Cabernet Sauvignon is a bold, polished red from Coonawarra, one of Australia’s top Cabernet regions. It’s packed with flavors of blackberry, blackcurrant, and dark plum, with subtle notes of cedar, mint, and spice. The tannins are smooth and well-integrated, giving it a clean, structured finish. A modern, vibrant Cabernet that’s perfect for pairing with hearty meals or enjoying on its own.
Ready to Buy The Best Reds Under $25—Handpicked Just for You
We put together all 12 of the above wines plus two more bottles that we like just as much and you can get them delivered to you for FREE. Ditch the grocery store brands. Buy them in a 12-bottle case here.
Share:
9 Reasons Why You Should Consider Having a Wine Club Membership
Top 12 Bordeaux Wines Available at BHW Now!
Comments Section