Spring Sale Get Up to 20% on selected items

What has us most excited about today’s offer, besides the fine wine in bottles​​? It’s the way we see you enjoying the 2015 & 2016 Mazzei Fonterutoli Siepi Toscana. These are wines you can hold on to, certainly, but they’re also ready to open now, and we have a vision of a mini-vertical tasting with a companion or two.

What’s a vertical tasting? It’s when you open the same wines, usually from the same producer, from different vintages to compare their qualities. Why would the same wine from the same producer vary from year to year? The climate has a lot to do with it. Everything from how early the buds on the vine broke to rain the day before harvest can influence a wine. 

Fortunately, 2015 and 2016 were “two great vintages,” according to Suckling, also calling the 2015 Fonterutoli Siepi Toscana “a triumph” and the 2016 “a masterpiece.” Parker’s Wine Advocate declared the 2016 the best vintage of Siepi tasted so far, giving it 96 points.

Even in less than stellar years, the Mazzei family knows how to make quality wines because they’ve been doing it for 26 generations! The family has owned the Siepi vineyard since 1435, at first working with indigienous Italian grapes like Sangiovese. In the early 1980s they had the foresight to plant Merlot. This premier Italian estate now puts equal amounts of both in their Fonterutoli Siepi Toscana.

Both excellent vintages have notes of elder, plum, berries, sandalwood, and tobacco, with very long, bright finishes. But, there are noticeable differences between the two years, and this is why the idea of a vertical tasting excites us. Does one have more leather? Does one have more of a crushed stone/gravel component? How do the tannins feel in the 2015 compared to the 2016? Comparing the two sounds like a fun way to spend an evening, right?

Of course, you can simply enjoy these wines one at a time or both together with a classic tomato-sauced pasta, game, or rich mushroom dishes.

Here’s today’s offer. Both bottles together could cost you $300, but we have both of them for $174.99. That’s 42% off when you buy two excellent wines from two excellent vintages. You can also purchase the 2015 Mazzei Fonterutoli Siepi Toscana alone for 88.99 or the 2016 Mazzei Fonterutoli Siepi Toscana alone for 88.99, each at a 40% discount. 

Whether you buy the two together or just one of the vintages, we know you’re going to delight in these critically lauded wines made from a storied Tuscan winery with a history of producing award-winning wine since its inception.

buy now

Orange wine cocktail served poolside with fresh citrus and summer fruit on a sunny afternoon

READ FULL ARTICLE

Graduation party wine selection featuring sparkling wine, white wine, rosé, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Pinot Noir for a summer celebration

READ FULL ARTICLE

Couple enjoying glasses of Chardonnay at an outdoor garden dinner table during golden hour with a wine bottle and appetizers nearby.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Family and friends celebrating Memorial Day outdoors with wine, grilled food, American flags, and string lights during a backyard dinner party.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Bozoma Saint John Blended Her Wedding Wine at Villa Bibbiani. Here's Where to Get Yours.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Wine fraud concept with red wine bottle and glass on newspapers highlighting scams and counterfeit wine issues

READ FULL ARTICLE

Glass of red wine on a barrel inside a cellar with rows of aging oak barrels in the background.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Woman enjoying a glass of rosé wine in a garden setting, perfect Mother’s Day wine gift moment

READ FULL ARTICLE

Several glasses of red wine in a line overa wood countertop.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Winemaker holding a glass of red wine in a barrel cellar, highlighting craftsmanship and hands-on winemaking

READ FULL ARTICLE

Laptop with spreadsheet on desk next to red wine glass, map, and corkscrew overlooking vineyard landscape

READ FULL ARTICLE

Chilled red wine bottle in marble cooler with glass of light red wine on table by window

READ FULL ARTICLE

Brunello di Montalcino 2021 wine bottle with grapes overlooking Tuscan vineyards at sunset.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Michel Rolland on a winery.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Person browsing an online wine shop on a tablet at home, comparing bottles and prices

READ FULL ARTICLE

Aged wine bottle in cellar with barrels representing imported wine affected by U.S. tariffs and pricing changes

READ FULL ARTICLE

Red wine being poured into glass with dark background and soft lighting.

READ FULL ARTICLE

An old bottle of wine in a cellar.

READ FULL ARTICLE

A woman and a man serving wine on a backyard during spring time.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Hand holding vineyard soil in a family-owned vineyard illustrating terroir and why wine changes every vintage.

READ FULL ARTICLE

añejo tequila amaro cocktail with vermouth and Averna served in a Nick & Nora glass

READ FULL ARTICLE

A group of three women celebrating with wine.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Friends enjoying wine together during a wine tasting conversation about grape varieties and wine regions.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Wide landscape shot of Donum Estate vineyards.

READ FULL ARTICLE

A glass wine on a countertop next to a science book with some reading glasses.

READ FULL ARTICLE

A shot of mezcal with a worm inside of it.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Person decanting red wine into a glass decanter in a wine cellar.

READ FULL ARTICLE

A cellar with six different wine bottles.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Four wine glasses with different colors inside a cellar with oak barrels.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Assorted fresh tortelloni at an Italian pasta counter, including ricotta, artichoke, and truffle varieties.

READ FULL ARTICLE

German Chateau with Riesling wine bottles.

READ FULL ARTICLE

How to Open a Wax-Sealed Wine Bottle (3 Easy Methods)

READ FULL ARTICLE

The Wine Industry's Dirty Secret: Why There's No Ingredient List on Your Bottle

READ FULL ARTICLE

Sulfur in Wine: What You Need to Know

READ FULL ARTICLE

Why 2022 Bordeaux Might Be the Smartest (and Freshest) Buy of the Decade

READ FULL ARTICLE

Why 2020 Bordeaux Is the Sleeper Vintage You Should Be Buying Right Now

READ FULL ARTICLE

Beach, Please! The Hottest Summer Wines to Savor

READ FULL ARTICLE

Summer 2025 Wine Market Update: The View from Inside the Biz of Buying Volume Deals

READ FULL ARTICLE

Uncork the Best Wine for the Fourth of July

READ FULL ARTICLE

Master Wine Tasting with BLIC Method - Balance, Length, Intensity, and Complexity Explained

READ FULL ARTICLE

12 Best Red Wines Under $50 from California To Buy Now from Big Hammer Wines

READ FULL ARTICLE

Italian Ambassador's Top 12 Italian Red Wines to Buy Today at BHW

READ FULL ARTICLE

Top 12 White Wines to Buy at BHW Now

READ FULL ARTICLE

Top 15 Bestselling Wines at BHW That Are Still Available

READ FULL ARTICLE

Top 10 Portuguese Wines of 2024 Oporto Tasting & Judging

READ FULL ARTICLE

2022 Bordeaux Vintage in Review

READ FULL ARTICLE

Antonio Galloni’s Five Key Characteristics to Evaluate a Vintage

READ FULL ARTICLE

Greg's Picks Founder's Favorites Available Now

READ FULL ARTICLE

The Breakfast Price Index: Where Morning Sustenance Costs More Than a Decent Bottle of Wine

READ FULL ARTICLE

So, What is the Difference Between Barolo and Barbaresco?

READ FULL ARTICLE

Willamette Valley & Portland: The BigHammer Insider's Wine Country Travel Guide

READ FULL ARTICLE

Red wine bottle and glass overlooking Montepulciano, Tuscany at sunset.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Burgundy wine bottles in stone cellar representing value wines from Burgundy region

READ FULL ARTICLE

The Complete Rome Wine & Dining Guide for Wine Lovers

READ FULL ARTICLE

Traditional Georgian qvevri cellar with rows of buried clay vessels.

READ FULL ARTICLE

A Wine Lover’s Guide to the Bordeaux Wine Region

READ FULL ARTICLE

Baja California Travel Guide: Explore this Unique Mexican Wine Region

READ FULL ARTICLE

A True Wine Insider’s Guide to Napa Valley: The Ultimate Guide to Napa Valley 2025

READ FULL ARTICLE

Local Wine & Dining in Rome | Travel Guide for Wine Lovers

READ FULL ARTICLE

Guide to Capri: Where to Stay Eat and Drink, without a Boat!

READ FULL ARTICLE

EU Winemakers Heading for the Hills: Climate Change Rewrites the Wine Map

READ FULL ARTICLE

Vino Nobile di Montepulciano: The Tuscan Wine That’s Redefining Excellence

READ FULL ARTICLE

How the Judgment of Paris Shook Up the Wine World

READ FULL ARTICLE

What is Port Wine? Learn More About Port Styles, History and What to Pair it With

READ FULL ARTICLE

Bordeaux Travel Guide 2024: Walking Tour in Bordeaux City - Local's Ultimate Food & Wine Insider Tips

READ FULL ARTICLE

Wines of Croatia: A Taste of the Adriatic

READ FULL ARTICLE

The Best Burgundy Vintages in the Past 20 Years

READ FULL ARTICLE

Italian Wine Ambassador’s Insider Notes on the 2019 Brunello di Montalcino Vintage Blog - Big Hammer Wines

READ FULL ARTICLE

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon: Oakville vs. Rutherford

READ FULL ARTICLE

Barolo Brilliance: Unraveling the Mystique of Piedmont's Noble Nebbiolo

READ FULL ARTICLE

Several glasses of red wine in a line overa wood countertop.

READ FULL ARTICLE

Why 2022 Bordeaux Might Be the Smartest (and Freshest) Buy of the Decade

READ FULL ARTICLE

Why 2020 Bordeaux Is the Sleeper Vintage You Should Be Buying Right Now

READ FULL ARTICLE

12 Best Red Wines Under $50 from California To Buy Now from Big Hammer Wines

READ FULL ARTICLE

Italian Ambassador's Top 12 Italian Red Wines to Buy Today at BHW

READ FULL ARTICLE

Top 12 White Wines to Buy at BHW Now

READ FULL ARTICLE

Top 15 Bestselling Wines at BHW That Are Still Available

READ FULL ARTICLE

Greg's Picks Founder's Favorites Available Now

READ FULL ARTICLE

Aglianico Lovers: Meet the 99-Point Wine Named “Barolo of the South”!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Feeling ⛓️Like a Wine Prisoner? Break Free with This Top-Rated 2019 Napa Blend

READ FULL ARTICLE

Love Rhône Valley? This is the sample pack for you!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Verona Sampler

Verona Sampler

READ FULL ARTICLE

Red Burgundy Sampler

Red Burgundy Sampler

READ FULL ARTICLE

Calling All Bordeaux Rouge Fans!

READ FULL ARTICLE

The Right Bank Bordeaux Sampler, Experience Epic Wines

READ FULL ARTICLE

Love Rhône Valley? This is the sample pack for you!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Escape to Summer with this Rosé Adventure!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Pop The Bubbly & Embark On A Global Fizz Adventure!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Premier Wine Club 6pk Sampler: Greg Martellotto's Personal Favorites, Perfect for Sharing with Friends and Family!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Big Bold Reds 6pk Sampler: Perfect for Those Who Crave Bright, Fruity Wines with a Bold Punch!

READ FULL ARTICLE

Talosa Rosso Toscano Di Montepulciano

READ FULL ARTICLE

Fun, Italian Fizz. Unfiltered Prosecco that is NOT Sweet – BHW's Best Bargain!

READ FULL ARTICLE

For Bordeaux Lovers: The Right Bank Bordeaux 6pk Sampler. Experience Merlot and Cab FrancBased Epicness

READ FULL ARTICLE

A BudgetFriendly Journey through Enchanting Bordeaux Right Bank PetitChateaux!

READ FULL ARTICLE

2022 RaimbaultPineau Exception Sancerre

READ FULL ARTICLE

READ FULL ARTICLE

2015 Château Bourseau Lalande de Pomerol Reviewed by Big Hammer Wines “French” Wine Expert

READ FULL ARTICLE

Quality, Style, and Convenience. Get this EasytoUse ItalianMade Corkscrew Today! Sommelier Approved.

READ FULL ARTICLE